Keep Sanibel taxpayers out of federal subrecipient for Riverview II
I support Community Housing & Resource’s (CHR) mission to provide affordable housing for Sanibel workforce, but nevertheless I urge the City Council and the County Commission to keep Sanibel taxpayers out of the role of federal subrecipient for Riverview ll.
The question is not whether we need workforce housing. It is who repays $9.75 million in federal money if something goes wrong over the next 30 years.
Under Lee County’s proposed terms, Sanibel taxpayers would lend the money to CHR, enforce a 30-year affordability covenant, and repay any disallowed costs “without conditioning the County’s recovery on successful collection from CHR.” In plain English: Sanibel taxpayers pay even if CHR can’t and that responsibility lasts the entire 30 years.
Repayment is not the only burden. As subrecipient, the City would also be required to take on 30 years of federal compliance, monitoring, and reporting, with the City staff time and cost that come with it, long after today’s CHR Board, City Council, and staff have moved on.
The County’s own independent reviewer found that Riverview ll’s rents cannot cover its mortgage. The County’s underwriting shows the Riverview ll project running about $500,000 short every year. Closing that gap depends on two sources. The first is the Sanibel taxpayers annual contribution to CHR: nearly $450,000 in 2027, and it grows every year. The second is assumed fundraising, events, and grants, which the reviewer called “not standard” underwriting. This means it’s hypothetical. In 2027, that target is more than $1.7 million to cover all of CHR’s properties, more than three times what CHR has averaged in non-hurricane years. Imagine City Council presenting in their budget meeting that last year they collected $15 million in property taxes, and then present a budget assuming $40 million will be collected the next year. That would be reckless. Over 30 years, CHR’s plan relies on about $56 million in donations, events, and grants and $23 million from Sanibel taxpayers. And with Amendment 3 set to shrink property-tax revenue and limit what municipalities can fund, support for non-profits may be among the first things squeezed when government has to prioritize.
Sanibel Captiva Community Bank is providing financing for this more than $17 million project and is first in line for repayment. Harkey House (built with donor grants and a $1.25 million SHIP loan from Lee County), Riverview ll, and 4 CHR properties in Lake Palms have all been pledged as collateral. None of these mortgages came before City Council, as the City code requires. The bank is protected. Sanibel taxpayers would not be.
Ask the simple question: what happens if CHR merges, dissolves, or defaults in year 10, or year 25? The bank takes the collateral. The federal government comes to the City. And the City has nothing to fall back on but the people who pay its taxes.
Some point to the $46 million in other recovery grants Sanibel has received. Those fund City studies, City roads, and a City police station. The fire district has ad valorem taxes, a short construction period, and backup funding in hand if its grant were pulled. None of these grants are for 30 years, typically 2. Riverview ll is fundamentally different: a 30-year loan to a nonprofit with no backstop but Sanibel taxpayers and “hypothetical” giving which needs to grow every year. The City Manager and the City should not take on a risk no other project has required
Remember, too, that CHR itself did not want the City to be the subrecipient and told both the City Council and County Commission so. Council gave direction that the City would not be the subrecipient, yet here we are again.
The Sanibel City Council has a special meeting on Nov. 23, at 9 a.m. The County Commission takes this up on Dec. 1 at 9:30 am. I encourage residents to attend or write to Sanibel City Council before then: sancouncil@mysanibel.com.
Sanibel City Council: please don’t put Sanibel taxpayers at risk for decades to come. Do the right thing. Decline the subrecipient role.
Denise P. Rodenburg
Sanibel Resident