Short-form applications for development permits to sunset at end of year
By MEGHAN BRADBURY
mbradbury@breezenewspapers.com
The Sanibel City Council approved the sunset of short-form applications at the end of the year for development permits during a meeting earlier this month.
The city council approved a motion that eliminates the provision on Dec. 31, 2026, taking the process back to long-form applications. Councilmembers Holly Smith and Richard Johnson voted against the motion.
Mayor Mike Miller said the motion for Ordinance 26-022 from the Planning Commission was to do nothing and allow the provision to expire. He said it was brought before city council, so they had the opportunity to do something differently.
“The actual proposal from the Planning Commission is to let it die,” he said.
Deputy Planning Director Gabriel Quintas said the Planning Commission voted to allow it to sunset and the reason was relating to concerns about giving citizens an opportunity to voice concerns over these applications in a public hearing.
“I would also like to convey Commissioner Burns vote of no, simply because she requested it to be conveyed at the meeting that she had concerns related to encouraging conformity for build back situations,” he said.
Quintas said building back either a nonconforming structure or a nonconforming use within a nonconforming structure that has been destroyed or substantially damaged by a natural disaster within the three-dimensional outline of the lawfully existing habitable area of the pre-disaster building, but the footprint of the lawfully existing pre-disaster building is moved in a manner that reduces the pre-disaster building’s encroachment into the Gulf Beach Zone, normally has to be approved by the Planning Commission.
With the provision it is allowed to be done administratively.
“I believe her concern was we would be discouraging that greater conformity if we required it to go back to Planning Commission,” Quintas said.
He said the code establishes two types of development permits — short form, which are approved by staff, and long form, which require approval from the Planning Commission.
The code allows for three types of long-form development permits to be reviewed and approved by staff for a limited period of time because of Hurricane Ian recovery — all that require a variance or waiver, conditional use permits, and building back the nonconforming structure or use within the nonconforming structure.
The Planning Commission took a vote to let it expire in a 4-2 vote.
“Planning Commission’s recommendation is that those issues will all revert to long form after Dec. 31, 2026,” Miller said.
Smith said she did not think any of them would have known that “here we are four years later and as much as we thought things would be up and running and redone, they are not.”
“We are finally starting to see more of a confidence. Probably one of the reasons was we fortunately did not have any storms this past year. We are also seeing more confidence in lenders coming back and saying we are a place that we can lend more money to because we have more confidence in you as well,” Smith said. “I do not support the Planning Commission’s decision on this because I think we need more time to develop that 25% of the island that we have.”
Councilmember Laura DeBruce said her instinct is to follow the recommendation of the Planning Commission.
“Because our Planning Commission feels they should take these back, it feels like we may as well honor that,” she said. “They are looking at the underlying conditional use variance or waiver in any event.”
City Attorney John Agnew said that Director Paula McMichael supported the idea of it returning back to the Planning Commission because of the notion that it is really kind of a two-part thing and it is more efficiently addressed all in one.
Vice Mayor John Henshaw moved that they accept the Planning Commission’s discussion and reasoning for not extending the ordinance and allow the provision to sunset.
Councilmember Richard Johnson said he found himself in agreement with Smith.
“We are hitting that last segment of recovery. Many times that is going to be our toughest segment to get back done. If by keeping this as an administrative move — I think the message that we send is it may be more difficult going through those steps,” he said. “I don’t want to do anything to send that message. If we can send the message now that we are getting to that point that we are encouraging people to rebuild and encouraging to get their projects submitted and approved and moving forward, I think that is a good thing. I struggle with doing otherwise. My fear is that some may say now we have to go through the Planning Commission and it’s very public and maybe not move forward. I would like to do anything we can to move them forward,” he said.
Johnson moved to amend the motion with the following conditions — applications for development requiring a variance or a wavier and conditional use permits be returned to the Planning Commission, while leaving build back of nonconforming structures or nonconforming use in a nonconforming structure remain administratively. Johnson extended the sunset date of the building back of nonconforming structures and use until December 2027, while the other two would sunset at the end of 2026.
Henshaw said he had heart burn on extending it to ’27 and only because one of their objectives is to be more resilient, to push resiliency and push conformance with standards.
“For the next storm we will have the same problems if we don’t sort of push it and force people to make some tough decisions,” he said. “I am not in favor of extending it to December of ’27.”
Miller said it does not extend the date by which the applicant has to do something.
“This is a transition between going from a short form to a long form that it merely cuts off the short form process at Dec. 31, 2027,” he said.
Henshaw said the reason why they did it was to give people time, but not give people forever.
“At some point you have to fish cut bait. You have to decide we are going to freeze frame and not extend it any longer. We are only 75% (of our economic base). I understand that remaining 25 is tough. Is it going to be a lot easier — is it going to be significantly different in December ’27, I don’t know. The last little bit is going to be hard to achieve,” he said. “I don’t necessarily want to continue the short term process.”
Smith said she understood.
“More people are wanting to come. We really need our economic return and I think this hopefully will give an opportunity. Do we want to keep extending it every year? I never would have thought standing here four years later, we thought hopefully we would be done — and we are not,” she said.
Henshaw said he is under the belief that they are going to have another Helene, another Milton, but hopefully not another Ian.
“We are going to have another one — then we extend it further — then we might just live with a short form,” he said. “We were lucky this year. We may be lucky next year, but I think we are going to have to live with water over our island on a regular basis, whatever that is. At some point we have to say we have to get back to our norm, which is different than pre-Ian, pre-Milton and pre-Helene.”
DeBruce said they are not telling someone their deadline is extended.
“Instead of having this done administratively, you have to go to Planning Commission,” she said.
The amendment to the motion failed.